You know, I was looking at awfulplasticsurgery.com over the weekend, and I noticed the same thing there about the physical, you know "her butt is so perfect that it can't possibly be real, nobody has a butt that perfect" or "breasts that big aren't that naturally round and firm, they must be fake", but when you're a 21 year old movie star with a physical trainer and insurance on your body parts then, hey, maybe you do have a body that's too good to be true, maybe that's why you're 21 years old and a movie star or model or whatever.

People tend to assume that their own personal maximums apply to everyone else... if they can't possibly have a perfect body then it's impossible for anyone to have a perfect body, if they can't be nice and helpful to others without being fake, then genuinely nice people must be fake too. It shows more about the kind of person the judge is than the contestant (or just the topic of gossip outside of the reality show context), and it often doesn't show anything pleasant. : /